Search Site
Menu
25 Main Street, Suite 104 | Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
Call For Consultation 551-245-8894
Free Exercise and Employee Health Care Under the ACA

While the Affordable Care Act (ACA) has been in the news for a number of reasons lately, one story that largely fell by the wayside involved a Pennsylvania cabinet company that took issue with the ACA’s requirement that health plans provide coverage for certain types of oral contraceptives. A federal appellate decision in the case has contributed to a growing split among the appeals courts that is likely to ultimately go to the Supreme Court.

In Conestoga Wood Specialties Corp. v. Sebelius, a closely held corporation owned by a Pennsylvania Mennonite family asserted that the ACA’s requirements that employee health plans cover certain contraceptives infringed on the corporation’s right to free religious exercise under the First Amendment as well as its rights under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA). After losing in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, a divided panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit also denied Conestoga’s claim.

While acknowledging that the recent Citizens United decision from the U.S. Supreme Court had demonstrated that corporate entities can assert free speech rights, the Third Circuit found it inconceivable that a secular corporation could engage in religious exercise. Instead, the court held, such religious ideals were purely personal.

This is not the first time the issue has come before a federal court:

  • In 2012, a group of Catholic dioceses and organizations sued the Department of Health and Human Services over the ACA’s contraception requirements. The case, filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, was ultimately dismissed. Other such cases also were dismissed.
  • In 2013, the Sixth Circuit upheld a district court’s denial of a corporation’s request for an injunction against enforcement of the same provision of the ACA.
  • In 2013, the Tenth Circuit found that secular corporations could challenge the contraception provisions of the ACA on free exercise grounds.

The split among the circuits makes this issue a likely candidate for Supreme Court consideration. Employee rights attorneys will closely watch to see how this controversy could affect employee benefits.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Neil  H.  Deutsch Attorney Photo
Neil H. Deutsch
Senior Partner

About Neil H. Deutsch has been practicing law for over 35 years and is known as a skilled negotiator in employment and discrimination law. He believes in a bottom-line approach of risk analysis and cost effectiveness for his clients. "Case evaluation is something we take seriously," says Mr. Deutsch who seeks top net dollar for…

Bruce  L.  Atkins Attorney Photo
Bruce L. Atkins
Senior Partner

About Bruce L. Atkins is regarded as one of New Jersey's premiere practitioners of employment and civil litigation. Mr. Atkins has also been included in the Thomson Reuters list of New Jersey Super Lawyers* in Employment Litigation since 2005. Mr. Atkins believes employees have rights that should be aggressively pursued when an employer has wrongfully dealt…

Adam  J.  Kleinfeldt Attorney Photo
Adam J. Kleinfeldt
Partner

About Adam J. Kleinfeldt joined Deutsch Atkins, P.C. in March of 2015.  He primarily represents individuals in employment litigations such as discrimination, retaliation, and whistle blowing matters.  He has extensive experience in all phases of the litigation process. Adam has obtained significant results for some of his clients, including a $525,000 jury verdict in a…

Robert  J.  Pantina Attorney Photo
Robert J. Pantina
Attorney

About Robert J. Pantina joined the firm in 2018. Mr. Pantina received his B.A. from Rider University in 2008. He received his J.D. from the Elisabeth Haub School of Law at Pace University in 2017. While in law school, Mr. Pantina interned for the Hon. Bonnie J. Mizdol, Assignment Judge of the Superior Court of…

Diane  Englander  Peyser Attorney Photo
Diane Englander Peyser
Attorney

About Diane Englander Peyser joined Deutsch Atkins, PC in September 2018 where she represents employees in wrongful termination, retaliation, harassment, and discrimination matters. Prior to joining Deutsch Atkins, PC, Diane represented clients in all aspects of employment law on behalf of employees involving unemployment appeals, claims of sexual harassment, LGBT discrimination, disability discrimination, FMLA, New…

AWARDS & AFFILIATIONS
Reviews and Ratings
  • lawyers
    5.0/5.0

    No description provided

    Read more

    Partner

  • lawyers
    5.0/5.0

    No description provided

    Read more

    Partner

  • lawyers
    5.0/5.0

    No description provided

    Read more

    Partner

  • lawyers
    5.0/5.0

    No description provided

    Read more

    Sole Practitioner

  • lawyers
    4.4/5.0

    No description provided

    Read more

    Partner

See all reviews
Contact us

Quick Contact Form